The Rest of the Short Sale Story

I read a story about short sales in today's local newspaper. Although it was accurate, it told only half of the story. As a real estate and tax attorney, I have consulted with about 300 homeowners regarding the legal and tax ramifications of short sales and foreclosures.

What is missing from the story is 1) why we went from zero distressed properties to 45% of the properties being in that situation, 2) why the banks (in reality servicing companies) drag out the short sale procedure, sometimes without a sale being made, and 3) how they are still defrauding the government and taxpayers with the after sale or foreclosure documents they file with IRS after the transaction. I cover the first two in my book, “Greed-American Dream Becomes the Global Nightmare.” The last one is a new twist to the puzzle.

1. The reason that the number of distressed properties has increased is solely attributable to the actions of the Federal government and the lending institutions. The problem could have been nipped in the bud had different actions taken place in 2007. The banks, which created the problem with their weapons of mass destruction (easy credit, subprime loans, and mortgage-backed securities), handled the problem like they had for 100 years: foreclose and sell the property quickly at below market value, just to get it out of their portfolio. That worked fine in the past, when there were down payments and verification of income required on home loans. However, there were millions of loans that had been made in which there was no equity.

If someone then needed to sell their home in the same neighborhood, they were facing a fair market value of less than what they owed. At that time, getting a short sale through was next to impossible because the banks were not staffed with anyone to handle them, and they failed to look at the problem logically based upon the lack of equity in property, and that the manner in which they addressed the problem would simply make it worse.

2. In the vast majority of short sale transactions, the banks are not the lenders. The scheme that they put together was to make loans, package them into trusts, turn them into securities which they would get rated as AAA by Standard & Poor’s or Moody’s, then sell them to unsuspecting investors throughout the world. They made money creating the loans, selling the loans, and after the sale had maintained the right to service the loans, which provided them with ongoing income.
When a mortgage goes into default, the fee charged to the investor by the servicer is higher than when not in default. The longer the property is in default, the more money the servicing bank makes. If there is a modification of the loan, the banks do not get paid in a lump sum, but must wait for their payment, just like the investor. When there is a short sale or a foreclosure, the servicing bank gets paid immediately from the funds at the sale of the property, with the balance going to the investor. They have built in their own profit structure.

3. The latest fraud is that they are issuing fraudulent 1099’s to the previous owner, in such a manner that benefits the lender or the servicing bank at the expense of the taxpayers or the homeowners. I am in the process of preparing a lawsuit against Chase Mortgage based upon a fraudulent 1099-A. Chase foreclosed on a property and reported to San Luis Obispo County that the fair market value was $143,000.00. This reduces the property taxes that would be required to be paid to the County. When they issued the 1099-A, it showed a fair market value as $345,000.00! They then sold the property for $120,000.00. By doing this, they created a fraudulent $225,000.00 capital loss to offset other capital gains that they might have had, all at the expense of the taxpayers and the property owner, who was actually entitled to that capital loss, because it was investment property.

Although demand has been made to correct the 1099-A, and it has been reported by me to both IRS and the County Assessor’s office, nothing has been done.

I think it is important that people start demanding an investigation these issues by our elected representatives, Democrats and Republicans, why they are allowing our country and its people continue to suffer for the benefit of the stock market, which in no way truly reflects the health of the nation.